What are the pros and cons of using bottom-up vs. top-down costing approaches? (2024)

Bottom-up costing is a method that starts from the smallest units of work or resources and adds them up to get the total cost of the project. For example, you may break down the project into tasks, subtasks, and activities, and then estimate the hours, materials, equipment, and overheads required for each one. This method is often used when you have detailed specifications, historical data, or similar projects to compare with.

The main advantage of bottom-up costing is that it can provide a more accurate and realistic estimate of the project costs, as it reflects the actual work and resources involved. It can also help you identify and manage the risks, dependencies, and assumptions associated with each element of the project. However, the main drawback of bottom-up costing is that it can be very time-consuming and complex, as it requires a lot of data collection, analysis, and validation. It can also be affected by changes in scope, quality, or schedule during the project execution.

Top-down costing is a method that starts from the total budget or target cost of the project and allocates it to the major components or phases of the project. For example, you may use a percentage, a ratio, or a formula to distribute the available funds among the project deliverables, milestones, or work packages. This method is often used when you have limited information, high uncertainty, or tight deadlines.

The main advantage of top-down costing is that it can provide a quick and simple estimate of the project costs, as it does not require a lot of details or calculations. It can also help you align the project scope and objectives with the available resources and the client's expectations. However, the main drawback of top-down costing is that it can be less accurate and reliable, as it relies on assumptions, estimations, or historical averages that may not reflect the current or specific conditions of the project. It can also lead to over- or under-budgeting, as it does not account for the variations or contingencies that may arise during the project execution.

When deciding which costing method to use for bid preparation, there is no one-size-fits-all solution as it depends on various factors. For example, the type, size, complexity, and duration of the project, the level of detail and accuracy required, the availability and quality of data, and the preferences and expectations of the client. In general, bottom-up costing is best when you have a well-defined scope, a clear breakdown of work and resources, and sufficient time and expertise to collect and analyze data. On the other hand, top-down costing should be used when you have a vague or flexible scope, a high-level overview of work and resources, and limited time or expertise to collect and analyze data. A combination of both methods is recommended when you have a mixed or evolving scope, a moderate level of detail and accuracy required, and some reliable data and benchmarks to compare with.

No matter the costing method you select, there are some best practices to ensure that your bid is competitive, realistic, and profitable. To start, involve relevant stakeholders such as the project team, the client, the suppliers, and the subcontractors in the costing process. This will provide valuable inputs and feedback. Additionally, review and update cost estimates regularly as the project progresses and new information becomes available. This will help avoid any surprises or errors. Furthermore, document and justify assumptions, calculations, and sources of data to ensure transparency and credibility of your cost estimates. Additionally, include a contingency or reserve fund to cover any unexpected costs that may arise during project execution. Lastly, compare your cost estimates with similar or previous projects to check for consistency, accuracy, and competitiveness.

This is a space to share examples, stories, or insights that don’t fit into any of the previous sections. What else would you like to add?

Bid Preparation

+ Follow

Thanks for your feedback

Your feedback is private. Like or react to bring the conversation to your network.