Ionised Water: Separating Fact from Fiction (2024)

Introduction

Ionised water, also known as alkaline water, has gained significant attention in recent years as a potential health-promoting beverage. This electrically charged water, with a pH typically higher than regular drinking water, has sparked debates among health enthusiasts and scientists alike. As consumers seek ways to optimise their health through dietary choices, understanding the facts about ionised water becomes increasingly important.

Ionised water is produced through a process called electrolysis, which uses an electrical current to separate water molecules into acidic and alkaline components (Sharma & Bhattacharya, 2017). This process results in water with a higher pH level, usually between 8 and 9 on the pH scale, compared to the neutral pH of 7 found in most tap water. Proponents of ionised water claim it offers various health benefits, ranging from improved hydration to potential disease prevention. However, it's crucial to approach these claims with a critical eye and examine the available scientific evidence.

This comprehensive guide aims to explore the world of ionised water, delving into its production process, potential benefits, safety considerations, and how it compares to regular water. We'll examine the current state of research, including studies on its effects on acid reflux, cardiovascular health, and blood sugar management. Additionally, we'll discuss practical aspects such as how to obtain ionised water, its cost implications, and environmental considerations. By the end of this article, readers will have a well-rounded understanding of ionised water, enabling them to make informed decisions about its potential role in their health regimen.

Here is a draft of the main body content for the article on ionised water:

Understanding Ionised Water: A Comprehensive Guide

What is Ionised Water?

Ionised water, also known as alkaline water, is water that has undergone a process of electrolysis to alter its chemical composition and pH level. The pH scale ranges from 0 to 14, with 7 being neutral. Regular drinking water typically has a pH close to 7, while ionised water generally has a higher pH between 8 and 9.5, making it more alkaline (Sharma & Bhattacharya, 2017).

The process of water ionisation involves passing water through an electrolysis chamber containing positive and negative electrodes. As electricity flows through the water, it separates the water molecules (H2O) into positively charged hydrogen ions (H+) and negatively charged hydroxide ions (OH-). The positive hydrogen ions are drawn to the negative electrode, creating acidic water, while the negative hydroxide ions are attracted to the positive electrode, producing alkaline water (Heil & Seifert, 2016).

Key components of ionised water include:

1. Alkaline minerals: The process concentrates alkaline minerals like calcium, magnesium, and potassium in the water.

2. Negative oxidation-reduction potential (ORP): Ionised water typically has a negative ORP, which is thought to indicate antioxidant properties.

3. Smaller water cluster size: Some proponents claim that ionisation reduces the size of water molecule clusters, potentially improving hydration, though this remains scientifically unproven.

The Science Behind Water Ionisation

The electrolysis process used in water ionisation is based on well-established principles of electrochemistry. When an electrical current is passed through water containing dissolved minerals, it causes a series of redox reactions at the electrodes.

At the cathode (negative electrode):2H2O + 2e- → H2 + 2OH-

At the anode (positive electrode):2H2O → O2 + 4H+ + 4e-

These reactions result in the production of hydrogen gas and hydroxide ions at the cathode, making the water more alkaline, and oxygen gas and hydrogen ions at the anode, creating acidic water (Hanaoka, 2001).

Water ioniser devices typically use platinum-coated titanium electrodes to facilitate this process. The effectiveness of ionisation depends on several factors, including:

• Mineral content of the source water
• Electrical current strength
• Flow rate of water through the device
• Design and efficiency of the electrolysis chamber

It's important to note that the ionisation process in these devices differs from natural water ionisation that occurs in nature. Natural ionisation happens when water flows over rocks and minerals, gradually absorbing alkaline mineral compounds. This process can take years or even decades, resulting in naturally alkaline spring waters.

Types of Ionised Water

1. Alkaline ionised water: This is the most common type, with a pH typically between 8 and 9.5. It's produced at the cathode during electrolysis and is the type most often promoted for drinking.

2. Acidic ionised water: With a pH usually between 4 and 6, this water is produced at the anode. While not recommended for drinking, it's sometimes used for cleaning or skin care.

3. Neutral pH ionised water: Some ionisers can produce water with a neutral pH (around 7) that has undergone electrolysis but maintains a balanced pH.

Potential Benefits of Ionised Water

While proponents of ionised water claim numerous health benefits, it's crucial to approach these claims critically and examine the available scientific evidence. Here are some areas where research has been conducted:

Acid Reflux Reduction

A study by Koufman and Johnston (2012) found that alkaline water with a pH of 8.8 might help deactivate pepsin, an enzyme involved in acid reflux. The researchers suggested that alkaline water could be beneficial as an adjunct treatment for reflux disease, especially when combined with a plant-based diet.

However, it's important to note that this study was conducted in vitro (in a laboratory setting), and more research is needed to confirm these effects in humans. Additionally, the long-term effects of consuming highly alkaline water on stomach acid production and overall digestion are not yet fully understood.

Cardiovascular Health

Some studies have investigated the potential effects of ionised water on cardiovascular health markers. A small study by Tanaka et al. (2016) found that drinking alkaline ionised water for 4 weeks led to slight reductions in blood viscosity in 100 adults. The researchers hypothesised that this could potentially improve blood flow, but larger, long-term studies are needed to confirm these effects and their clinical significance.

Another study by Weidman et al. (2016) examined the effects of high-pH alkaline water on blood viscosity after exercise-induced dehydration. The researchers found that consuming alkaline water resulted in a more efficient return to pre-exercise hydration status compared to regular water. However, this study was small (100 participants) and funded by an alkaline water company, highlighting the need for independent replication.

Blood Sugar Management

Limited research has explored the potential effects of ionised water on blood sugar levels. A small study by Otsuki et al. (2011) found that consuming alkaline ionised water was associated with lower fasting glucose levels in 36 participants with type 2 diabetes or impaired glucose tolerance. However, this study was observational and had a small sample size, so more rigorous research is needed to establish any causal relationship.

Antioxidant Properties

The negative oxidation-reduction potential (ORP) of ionised water is often cited as evidence of its antioxidant properties. In theory, a negative ORP could indicate the presence of free electrons that could neutralise harmful free radicals in the body. However, it's unclear whether drinking water with a negative ORP translates to meaningful antioxidant effects in the body.

A study by Heil et al. (2012) found that alkaline water with a negative ORP had a protective effect against exercise-induced oxidative stress in physically active men. However, this study was small (36 participants) and short-term, and more research is needed to confirm these findings and their long-term implications.

Safety Considerations and Potential Side Effects

While ionised water is generally considered safe for most healthy individuals, there are some potential concerns and side effects to consider:

Impact on Stomach Acid Production

The human stomach naturally produces hydrochloric acid, which is crucial for digestion and protection against harmful bacteria. Some experts worry that regularly consuming highly alkaline water could interfere with this process. However, research on this specific concern is limited.

A study by Koufman and Johnston (2012) suggested that alkaline water might have a buffering effect on pepsin, an enzyme involved in protein digestion, but the long-term implications of this are not fully understood. It's advisable to consult with a healthcare provider before making significant changes to your water consumption, especially if you have any digestive issues.

Mineral Balance and Deficiencies

While ionised water can contain beneficial minerals, relying solely on it as a mineral source could potentially lead to imbalances. The body requires a variety of minerals in specific ratios, which are typically obtained through a balanced diet.

A review by Fenton et al. (2016) highlighted the importance of considering the broader context of mineral intake when evaluating the potential benefits of alkaline water. The authors emphasised that there is currently insufficient evidence to support the use of alkaline water for preventing or treating nutrient deficiencies.

Medication Interactions

The altered pH of ionised water could potentially affect the absorption of certain medications. For example, some medications are designed to be absorbed in specific pH environments within the digestive tract.

A study by Lindberg et al. (2017) found that the absorption of some weak acids and bases can be affected by changes in gastrointestinal pH. While this study didn't specifically look at ionised water, it highlights the importance of considering potential interactions between alkaline water and medications.

It's crucial to consult with a healthcare provider or pharmacist before consuming ionised water if you're taking any medications, especially those that are pH-sensitive or have a narrow therapeutic window.

How to Obtain Ionised Water

There are several methods to obtain ionised water, each with its own considerations:

Home Water Ioniser Systems

Home water ionisers are devices that attach to your tap and use electrolysis to produce alkaline water on demand. These systems typically offer adjustable pH levels and may include additional filtration features.

Types of home ionisers include:- Countertop models- Under-sink systems- Portable ionisers

Installation and maintenance considerations:- Professional installation may be required for under-sink models- Regular cleaning and filter replacements are necessary- Mineral cartridges may need to be added in areas with soft water

Cost considerations:- Initial investment can range from a few hundred to several thousand dollars- Ongoing costs include electricity, filter replacements, and potential repairs

Bottled Alkaline Water

Many commercial brands offer bottled alkaline water, which can be a convenient option for those who don't want to invest in a home system.

Considerations:- Quality and pH can vary between brands- Environmental impact of plastic bottles- Potentially higher long-term cost compared to home systems

Alkaline Water Filters

These include pitcher filters and countertop systems that raise the pH of water through various methods, such as using mineral cartridges or ceramic balls.

Effectiveness and limitations:- Generally less expensive than electric ionisers- May not achieve as high a pH as electric systems- Limited control over pH levels

Natural Alkaline Water Sources

Some spring waters are naturally alkaline due to the minerals they absorb while flowing over rocks. These can be sourced directly from springs or purchased as bottled water.

Considerations:- Mineral content can vary depending on the source- May be more expensive than regular bottled water- Limited availability depending on location

Ionised Water vs. Regular Water: A Comparative Analysis

When comparing ionised water to regular tap or bottled water, several factors come into play:

pH Differences

• Regular tap water: Typically has a pH between 6.5 and 8.5, with most municipal water systems aiming for a neutral pH around 7.
• Ionised water: Generally has a pH between 8 and 9.5, depending on the ionisation process and settings used.

A study by Chycki et al. (2017) compared the effects of alkaline water (pH 9.5) to regular water (pH 7) on hydration status in 36 male athletes. While the alkaline water showed some benefits in terms of hydration markers, the authors noted that more research is needed to confirm these effects in different populations and settings.

Mineral Content Comparison

• Regular tap water: Mineral content varies widely depending on the source and treatment processes. Most tap water contains some level of calcium, magnesium, sodium, and other minerals.
• Ionised water: Often contains higher concentrations of alkaline minerals like calcium, magnesium, and potassium, which are concentrated during the ionisation process.

It's important to note that while ionised water may have higher mineral content, the bioavailability and absorption of these minerals in the body may not necessarily be improved compared to other dietary sources.

Oxidation-Reduction Potential (ORP)

• Regular water: Typically has a positive ORP, indicating an oxidising potential.
• Ionised water: Often has a negative ORP, which is claimed to have antioxidant properties.

A study by Heil and Seifert (2016) found that alkaline water with a negative ORP had potential benefits in terms of hydration and exercise performance. However, the authors emphasised the need for more research to confirm these effects and understand their long-term implications.

Taste and Palatability

Taste preferences for ionised versus regular water are subjective and can vary between individuals. Some people report that ionised water has a smoother or "cleaner" taste, while others may not notice a significant difference.

Factors affecting water taste include:- Mineral content- pH level- Presence of chlorine or other disinfectants (in tap water)- Temperature

A study by Azoulay et al. (2001) found that taste preferences for different types of water varied among participants, highlighting the subjective nature of water palatability.

Scientific Evidence and Research on Ionised Water

The current state of research on ionised water is characterised by a mix of promising preliminary findings and a need for more robust, long-term studies. Here's an overview of the existing evidence and areas requiring further investigation:

Current State of Research

Several studies have explored potential benefits of ionised water, including:

1. Acid reflux reduction: Koufman and Johnston (2012) found that alkaline water might help deactivate pepsin, an enzyme involved in reflux.

2. Hydration and exercise performance: Weidman et al. (2016) reported improved hydration status after exercise-induced dehydration with alkaline water consumption.

3. Blood viscosity: Tanaka et al. (2016) observed slight reductions in blood viscosity after consuming alkaline ionised water for 4 weeks.

4. Antioxidant effects: Heil et al. (2012) found potential protective effects against exercise-induced oxidative stress.

However, many of these studies have limitations, including small sample sizes, short durations, and potential conflicts of interest due to industry funding.

Conflicting Findings

While some studies suggest potential benefits, others have found no significant advantages of ionised water over regular water:

1. A systematic review by Fenton et al. (2016) concluded that there was a lack of evidence to support the use of alkaline water for the prevention or treatment of cancer.

2. Chycki et al. (2017) found mixed results when comparing alkaline water to regular water for hydration status in athletes, with some markers showing improvement while others showed no significant difference.

Need for Further Investigation

To establish the true effects of ionised water on health, several areas require more research:

1. Long-term safety and efficacy studies: Most existing research has been short-term, and the long-term effects of regular ionised water consumption are not well understood.

2. Mechanism of action: More research is needed to understand how ionised water might exert its proposed effects in the body.

3. Comparison with other interventions: Studies comparing ionised water to other dietary interventions or treatments for specific health conditions are lacking.

4. Replication of existing studies: Many of the positive findings need to be replicated in larger, independent studies to confirm their validity.

5. Population-specific effects: More research is needed to understand how ionised water might affect different populations, including those with specific health conditions.

   See Also

   Deluxe Alkaline Water Ionizer Machine 2L – Katy Craft

Practical Considerations for Ionised Water Use

For those considering incorporating ionised water into their daily routine, several practical aspects should be taken into account:

Daily Consumption Guidelines

While there are no official guidelines specifically for ionised water consumption, general hydration recommendations can be applied:

• The Australian Nutrient Reference Values suggest an adequate daily fluid intake of about 2.6 litres for men and 2.1 litres for women, including water from all sources (National Health and Medical Research Council, 2006).

It's important to note that these are general guidelines, and individual needs may vary based on factors such as activity level, climate, and overall health.

When consuming ionised water, it's generally recommended to:

1. Start gradually: Begin with lower pH levels (around 8.0) and gradually increase if desired.
2. Monitor your body's response: Pay attention to any changes in digestion, energy levels, or overall well-being.
3. Balance with regular water: It's not necessary to replace all water intake with ionised water. Many experts suggest alternating between ionised and regular water.

Cost Analysis

The cost of incorporating ionised water into your routine can vary significantly depending on the method chosen:

1. Home water ioniser systems:

   • Initial cost: $500 - $4000+ for a quality system
   • Ongoing costs: Filter replacements (every 6-12 months), electricity usage, potential repairs

2. Bottled alkaline water:

   • Cost per litre can range from $2 to $5 or more
   • Significantly more expensive than tap water in the long run

3. Alkaline water filters:

   • Initial cost: $50 - $200 for a pitcher or countertop system
   • Ongoing costs: Filter replacements (every 2-3 months)

When considering these options, it's important to weigh the potential benefits against the financial investment, especially given the current state of scientific evidence.

Environmental Impact

The environmental implications of ionised water consumption vary depending on the method used:

1. Home water ioniser systems:

   • Generally more environmentally friendly in the long term
   • Reduces plastic waste from bottled water
   • Energy consumption should be considered

2. Bottled alkaline water:

   • Contributes to plastic waste
   • Carbon footprint associated with production and transportation

3. Alkaline water filters:

   • Less plastic waste than bottled water
   • Filter cartridges may not be recyclable in all areas

When making a decision, consider the environmental impact alongside other factors such as cost and convenience.

Regulatory Stance and Health Claims

The regulatory landscape surrounding ionised water and associated health claims varies by country and region. In Australia, the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) regulates health claims made about food and beverages, including water products.

TGA Perspective

The TGA has not specifically approved any health claims related to ionised or alkaline water. In general, the TGA requires scientific evidence to support any therapeutic claims made about food or beverage products.

Key points

Conclusion

Ionised water remains a topic of ongoing scientific investigation and debate. While some studies suggest potential benefits in specific areas like acid reflux reduction and hydration, the overall body of evidence is still limited and often conflicting. The current research landscape is characterised by small-scale studies, short durations, and a lack of long-term safety data, making it challenging to draw definitive conclusions about the efficacy and safety of regular ionised water consumption.

Key points to consider:

1. Potential benefits: Some studies indicate possible advantages in areas such as hydration, acid reflux management, and antioxidant effects. However, these findings require further validation through larger, more rigorous studies.

2. Safety considerations: While generally considered safe for most healthy individuals, concerns exist about long-term consumption potentially affecting stomach acid production and mineral balance. Those with pre-existing health conditions or taking medications should consult healthcare providers before incorporating ionised water into their routine.

3. Cost and environmental impact: Home water ioniser systems can be a significant investment, while bottled alkaline water may contribute to plastic waste. These factors should be weighed against any potential benefits.

4. Regulatory stance: Health authorities like the TGA in Australia have not approved specific health claims related to ionised water, emphasising the need for robust scientific evidence to support such claims.

5. Need for further research: Larger, long-term studies are necessary to fully understand the effects of ionised water on various aspects of health and to confirm its safety for regular consumption.

In light of the current evidence, it's advisable for consumers to approach ionised water with a balanced perspective. While it may offer some benefits, it should not be viewed as a panacea or replacement for a healthy diet and lifestyle. Those interested in trying ionised water should start gradually, monitor their body's response, and consider it as part of a broader approach to health and hydration.

Ultimately, the decision to consume ionised water should be based on individual health needs, preferences, and consultation with healthcare professionals. As research in this field continues to evolve, staying informed about the latest findings will be crucial for making evidence-based decisions about ionised water consumption.

Key Highlights and Actionable Tips

• Ionised water has a higher pH (typically 8-9.5) compared to regular drinking water (pH ~7)

• It's produced through electrolysis, separating water into acidic and alkaline components

• Potential benefits include acid reflux reduction and improved hydration, but more research is needed

• Safety considerations include possible impacts on stomach acid production and mineral balance

• Consult a healthcare provider before consuming ionised water, especially if taking medications

• Start gradually with lower pH levels if trying ionised water and monitor your body's response

• Consider environmental impact and cost when choosing between home systems, filters, or bottled options

• Balance ionised water intake with regular water consumption

• Current evidence is limited - view ionised water as a potential complement to, not replacement for, a healthy diet and lifestyle

Is ionised water the same as alkaline water?

Ionised water and alkaline water are often used interchangeably, but there are some subtle differences. Ionised water specifically refers to water that has undergone electrolysis to separate it into acidic and alkaline components. While ionised water is typically alkaline, not all alkaline water is necessarily ionised. Some alkaline water is naturally occurring or produced through other methods like adding mineral compounds. The key similarity is that both have a pH above 7, making them more alkaline than regular drinking water.

Can ionised water help with weight loss?

There is currently no strong scientific evidence to support claims that ionised water directly contributes to weight loss. Some proponents suggest it may help by improving hydration or metabolism, but these claims lack robust research backing. A healthy diet and regular exercise remain the most evidence-based approaches for weight management. If you're considering ionised water for weight loss, it's best to consult with a healthcare professional or registered dietitian for personalised advice.

How does ionised water affect the gut microbiome?

The impact of ionised water on the gut microbiome is not well understood and requires further research. In theory, changes in water pH could potentially influence the gut environment, but whether this leads to meaningful changes in microbial populations or their functions is unclear. Some speculate that alkaline water might support beneficial bacteria, while others worry about disrupting the natural acidic environment of the stomach. Until more studies are conducted, it's difficult to draw conclusions about ionised water's effects on gut health.

Is it safe to use ionised water for cooking?

Using ionised water for cooking is generally considered safe, but it may affect the taste or texture of some foods. The higher pH could potentially impact the cooking process for certain dishes, especially those relying on specific chemical reactions. For example, it might affect the rise of baked goods or the setting of jellies. However, any effects are likely to be subtle for most everyday cooking. If you choose to cook with ionised water, you may want to experiment with small batches first to see if you notice any differences in your favourite recipes.

How does altitude affect the production and effectiveness of ionised water?

Altitude can potentially influence the production and properties of ionised water, primarily due to changes in atmospheric pressure and oxygen levels. At higher altitudes, water typically has a lower boiling point and may contain less dissolved oxygen. This could theoretically affect the electrolysis process used to create ionised water, possibly requiring adjustments to equipment settings. Additionally, the mineral content of water sources can vary with altitude, which may impact the final composition of ionised water. However, the practical significance of these factors for home users is likely minimal, and more research would be needed to determine any meaningful effects on the water's proposed health benefits.